I have often thought that when people say that they learn from their mistakes, it’s something to make them feel better in that moment. Something to quash the oft deep feelings of regret or shame or just plain humiliation. While I don’t doubt something is learnt from it, I don’t think it’s the grown experience people take it as. It, like many other things in life, have the effect of narrowing the options for next time, reducing potential experience.
Lives are like stories, each answer given closes off many doors, unlocking fewer in comparison. At the start, it’s not much of a problem. After all, as it’s setting up the story, they are doors you’re happy to close, options you do not wish to take. But, as the story progresses, you find yourself encountering the lesser of evil choices and the greatest of the goods. Doors are taken you’d otherwise prefer not to, other doors are closed which would have been great to take.
So, what does this have to do with learning from mistakes? The error, the mistake, is taken as a reason not to do that thing again, when it was only a mistake in that situation, in that time. There are so many variables, so many subtle differences so difficult to see, that the same actions, in the same order, could have the desired result.
I know this sounds like a rationalization, you weren’t wrong, the world conspired against you. Could be, but blaming yourself for the calamitous result is just the same type of assigning the blame, just to yourself rather than to uncontrollable factors. I’d categorize that as the same self-hate at the center of many major religions, giving their victories to the unconquered Sun while claiming all their losses to themselves.
Scientifically speaking, you’d need to repeatedly test the same actions to prove their lack of effect. That said, the act of observation changes the observed.
So, will I try again, another time, another place, another person? Sure. When the time is right, when the person is right. The contest is against my own record, my own failings. Not against the barriers of the world around me.
